Recognizes the annual top overall female and male FGCU Athletes performer, as collectively deemed by the coaching and administrative staff. The award is presented at the Welcome Back picnic each August.

Most Outstanding Athlete Award
Year Women's Recipient Sport Year Men's Recipient Sport
2013 Sarah Hansen Women's Basketball 2013 Sherwood Brown Men's Basketball
2012 Sarah Hansen Women's Basketball 2012 Ricky Knapp Baseball
2011 Shannon Murphy  Women's Basketball 2011 Adam Glick Men's Soccer
  Courtney Platt  Softball      
2010 Chelsea Lyles Women's Basketball 2010 Chris Sale Baseball
2009 Cheyenne Jenks Softball 2009 Josh Upchurch Baseball
2008 Carmen Paez Softball 2008 Jason Peacock Baseball
2007 Kate Schrader Women's Basektball 2007 Beau Bauer Men's Basketball
2006 Kate Schrader Women's Basketball 2006 Jason Louwsma Baseball
        Juan Carlos Osorio Men's Tennis
2005 Kelly Powe Softball 2005 Richard Stempnowski Men's Tennis
        Bryan Crislip Women's Basketball
2004 Kelly Powe Softball 2004 Leighton Bowie Men's Basketball
2003 Trish Fleming Women's Basketball 2003 Chris Brown Baseball